American Homes 4 Rent
American Homes 4 Rent Overview
The generated data is based on reviews and questionnaires provided by PissedConsumer.com users.
American Homes 4 Rent has a 1.3 star rating from 308 reviews; sentiment is largely negative with frequent reports of poor maintenance, communication failures, and disputed move‑out charges.
Key Takeaways for Future Customers
- Expect slow or unresponsive property management and customer service when issues arise.
- Document move‑in condition and payments to contest deposit deductions or billing errors.
- Be prepared for lengthy maintenance timelines and potential disputes over refunds.
Negative Feedback / Risk Areas
- Recurring complaints about customer service and property management ignoring urgent repairs.
- Frequent disputes over security deposit with alleged overcharges and unclear billing.
- Multiple reports requesting a refund or resolution that went unanswered.
Positive Feedback
Reviewers note convenient locations and that initial rental sign‑up can be straightforward; some maintenance issues were eventually resolved.
The generated data is based on reviews and questionnaires provided by PissedConsumer.com users.
American Homes 4 Rent has a 1.3 star rating from 308 reviews; sentiment is largely negative with frequent reports of poor maintenance, communication failures, and disputed move‑out charges.
Key Takeaways for Future Customers
- Expect slow or unresponsive property management and customer service when issues arise.
- Document move‑in condition and payments to contest deposit deductions or billing errors.
- Be prepared for lengthy maintenance timelines and potential disputes over refunds.
Negative Feedback / Risk Areas
- Recurring complaints about customer service and property management ignoring urgent repairs.
- Frequent disputes over security deposit with alleged overcharges and unclear billing.
- Multiple reports requesting a refund or resolution that went unanswered.
Positive Feedback
Reviewers note convenient locations and that initial rental sign‑up can be straightforward; some maintenance issues were eventually resolved.
Media from reviews





This review is from a real person who provided valid contact information and hasn't been caught misusing, spamming or abusing our website. Check our FAQ
Verified Reviewer |Abandoned Homes 4 rent house
I live next door to a home owned by AH4 Rent, they evicted the renters because of black mold, and maintenance issues that they refused to repair. Now the house is vacant, with maintenance issues, weeds three feet high covering the sidewalk, and is attracting vandals, and squatters.
I see people trying to break in.
I called the property management, and basically, they told me to call the police as they don't care, and just said they were aware of the problem but would not be doing anything about it. That house is attracting problems, and safety issues to our neighborhood and they couldn't care less.
Preferred solution: I would like that house to be maintained, the outside weeds and grass cut so it does not attract vandals, that obviously know the house is abandoned. Fix the issues with the house so a family can move in before squatters do
You Will Regret It
The HOA I live under fined me over $2000 for parking on my grass and damaging the lawn. The fines accrued over 6 months and AH4R did nothing to stop it or even inform me of the matter.
They refuse to speak with me.
the ah4r won't respond to me and they just pass on the fine like I am supposed to pay it.
I showed them photos that they were not my cars parked on the lawn but they absolutely ignored me. then they let the issue go to collections against ME... I'm not the property owner and I can't get anyone to listen as the fines keep accruing...
I'm just moving out without saying a word to them... They can take me to court.
User's recommendation: DO NOT SIGN A LEASE.. you will regret it...
This review is from a real person who provided valid contact information and hasn't been caught misusing, spamming or abusing our website. Check our FAQ
Verified ReviewerHouse falling apartment
I moved in in November and have opened over 14 work orders. Ive had plumbing issues (floods) discovered mold, appliances had to be replaced, furnace went out twice when it was in teens and no rush to fix.
The hot water tank was leaking. When they do send vendor out, nothing gets fixed immediately. It has taken over 2 weeks to get wall fixed where there was leak. And vendors never clean up.
This house is not safe. I am calling health department and have talked to attorney. Never again.
Dont rent from them. Slumlords.
User's recommendation: Do not rent from them - slumlords
This review is from a real person who provided valid contact information and hasn't been caught misusing, spamming or abusing our website. Check our FAQ
Verified ReviewerTry to warn future renters
Worst decision ever .
We had already put in a notice to move out in two months . AH4R had a new website for payments . I tried to make payments for 5 days using the new site and it would not take my payment .
I called them and the lady on the phone at the time said they were not allowed to take payments over the phone .. She told me to try web site again tomorrow that they know there were many issues going on and if that did not work mail it Las Vegas . I asked if I would be charged for a late fee, she said I don't think so . So for the next two days I tried using the site and nothing payment would just sit there and spin . So I mailed the payment off and before they even received it I get this eviction notice that I had 14 days to get out.. I'm thinking you cannot be serious ..
I called the *** and told them what had happen but did not matter they still refused to take my payment . So we just moved out that next weekend .. T
hey of course took are 2k security deposit and sued us for 5k .. to this day not sure where they came up with that number. I'm 62 and to this day only place
I have ever had a major issue with. Good luck and save yourself some pain and pick a better option.
- Total scam they run
- Customer service management
Preferred solution: Negotiate settlement . You have ripped me off for to damn long
User's recommendation: Stay far away as you can .. you will be sorry
This review is from a real person who provided valid contact information and hasn't been caught misusing, spamming or abusing our website. Check our FAQ
Verified ReviewerUnreasonable
I received a renewal letter for the home I've been in for going on 11 years. I counter offered and it has been over a month with no response.
I call. I email.
Nothing. I've had 5 different property management companies at this home and this is BY FAR the worst.
User's recommendation: Find a different house.
Need payment history
I live in this property for almost 3 years.
I need to move to an small apartment, they asked me for my payment history.
My address is 258 Meagan Beth rd Apopka Fl 32712
My e mail is Yayausa22.yt@***.com.
Thanks so much.
I have rented the same property from American Homes and can’t get them to replace the carpet
They constantly harass me about the driveway and sidewalk being pressure washed which we do but they want to send someone out and charge me $1000.00 as they did a few years back. I keep everything up at that house yet I cant even get them to replace the carpet that has been there for 11 years. They truly do NOT care about their residents and always looking for ways to get money from you for nothing.
User's recommendation: Do not rent from them
This review is from a real person who provided valid contact information and hasn't been caught misusing, spamming or abusing our website. Check our FAQ
Verified Reviewer |They won't give us our security deposit back or response to communications.
My wife and I have been out of 5213 Arbor View Lane, Sugar Hill GA 30518 since November. We have requested our security deposit be resent multiple times as we changed addresses and did not receive the original check.
We have emailed multiple times and called with no response. We want our security check back as it's been 4 months. This is ridiculous. AH4R is great to get you in the home but once you're in expect to have terrible customer service.
After you leave... crickets.
Preferred solution: Full refund
User's recommendation: RUN! Sounds great, nightmare once you move in.
This review is from a real person who provided valid contact information and hasn't been caught misusing, spamming or abusing our website. Check our FAQ
Verified ReviewerA valuable lesson from a BAD company
No response from them. Lost cause.
I am done and thankful only lost a hundred bucks. Hopefully, no future identity loss.
Today I am only out 100 bucks instead of thousands, and am thankful. Absolutely a sham company that hopefully does not sell sensitive personal. We ended the rental verification before it started.
Preferred solution: Full refund
User's recommendation: Do not rent from these thieves
This review is from a real person who provided valid contact information and hasn't been caught misusing, spamming or abusing our website. Check our FAQ
Verified ReviewerAwful company, epitome of greed.
Awful company, only cares about money, and could care less about the state of the property or the tenant as long as HOA isn't complaining
Impossible to reach your property manager or any supervisor. Our first contact with our PM Shameka Williams, was an email asking how she did and how the Move in experience was, this was after we'd moved in, reported numerous issues (2 yrs later, most were never addressed) had to find out for myself who our PM was and left her messages that she never responded to (but here's a survey).
We're in a nice house in a nice neighborhood paying almost 3k/m, we have a relatively nice side by side fridge but they didn't hook up the water and won't fix the ice maker. Lots of shotty work done before Move in and by maintenance along the way. They apparently put in new floors before we moved in but didn't put all the trim back so our kitchen Island (with an electrical outlet) slides around, they only put primer on the walls, not paint. Took 4 tries to get a new dishwasher installed properly.
The list goes on, companies like this shouldn't be allowed to do business but unfortunate they're taking advantage of the housing market and there's not much we can do. If you have the option go with private renter and avoid this company.
Preferred solution: Peace of mind, that companies like this would not be able to stay in business
User's recommendation: Avoid
They need to be closed down
So where do I start AMH needs to be closed down let me start off with the workers. Joie Hensley is rude and really do not like her job because I'm a client and she is my go-to person on my account she is supposed to supporter.
and keep people in the place but know she don't know how to talk to people or add. she added incorrect payments on my account then her boss Ashleigh Owens says they deals with a lot of account, and it was a mistake. Okay that was not my fault at all. AMH have all these extra fees.
and don't care about nothing but getting people money and taking them to court to try to get more money. They are scammers my house was so dirty when moving in I couldn't stay there for over a month until I got a cleaning company to come help me deep clean, they didn't care. again, this month extra fees are added on my account because they forgot to add the light bill and gas to last month's bill. I hate AMH and wouldn't tell nobody to rent to them.
BBB y'all need to close them down. they scammers and just takes people money the direct Ashley Edens is not good either. They just want to sit up and email you all day without picking up the phone to get a understanding and explain why are all these fees on my account. IF YOU LOOKING TO RENT FROM AMH DO NOT..
I WILL PASS THE WORD AND KEEP PASSING THE WORD UNTIL THEY ARE CLOSED. THEY REVIEW AND RATES ARE THE LOWEST CLOSED THEM DOWN HOW ARE THEY EVEN STILL TAKING PEOPLE MONEY THIS IS CRAZY..
This review is from a real person who provided valid contact information and hasn't been caught misusing, spamming or abusing our website. Check our FAQ
Verified ReviewerOnly rent from AH4R if it's your only choice!
Rent from AH4R if it's your only choice. We rented a home from them and stayed for a year and a half while our home was being built.
From the start, they made the process of making a deposit for the home Very difficult and kept giving all kinds of different answers as to how it was to be handled which made it very frustrating. The home was very tired and various shades of paint on the walls had been used over the years to cover holes or marks. For the most part everything worked okay. Over the length of our stay, we had a couple of issues, roof leak, water heater busted and a water heater element went bad.
To their credit, they had these issues resolved very quickly and we cannot complain about that at all. One thing that I'm very glad we did was take some detailed pictures of the condition of the rental when we moved in. Like ALL rental companies, they want to come up with Bogus claims that the property has been damaged or neglected and then charge you, so they can hang on to as much of your deposit money as possible. We left the home SPOTLESS!
And in far better condition than we received it. Even according to the Representative from AH4R doing the walk through after move out, he said it was in "Move in ready condition"! But they still wanted to charge me a $250 cleaning fee! Then they came up with several other bogus claims of damage, and when I disputed the claims with pictures, they relented and gave me back the money, but still charged me with a $125 cleaning fee.
So, make sure wherever you rent to detail the condition when you move in.
AH4R is just okay, I'm sure there are better and I know there are a lot worse. read less
Heather R.'s profile image
User's recommendation: Take detailed pictures of move in condition!!!!!!
This review is from a real person who provided valid contact information and hasn't been caught misusing, spamming or abusing our website. Check our FAQ
Verified ReviewerAmh horrible company
horrible company ... their service people came onto my property without permission ...
removed dirt from the side of my home and ac unit and put next to their house next to me ... $2000+ for me to repair damage and amh will not do anything ...
DO NOT RENT from them!!! service stinks and public relations is non existent
User's recommendation: DO NOT RENT f
Real Estate Expert Talks
This review is from a real person who provided valid contact information and hasn't been caught misusing, spamming or abusing our website. Check our FAQ
Verified ReviewerAMH homes are dirty, outdated and desperately need repairs.
The homes I have toured (3 to be exact) all need to be cleaned, painted, repaired. There are cracks in the ceilings, floors, tiles.
Floors had terrible scratches that nobody should be expected to live with. The smell of cigarette smoke was terrible. The vents/returns appeared to have not been cleaned in a long time. The paint was worn/outdated and needed to be redone.
The toilet in the masterbath was not secured well to the floor and moved when you touched it. I don't understand why such a large company would think they could get away with trying to rent a home to someone in the shape I saw these homes in today. I felt as if I was in a Section 8 home in a bad part of town (no disrepect intended at all). How is it ethically right to rent out an outdated, smelly, ill-repaired home to someone for $1800-$1900 per month.
I would not give them $500.00 per month for what I saw today. AMH you are a BIG company and making tons of money no doubt; however, you will not make any money off of me. Stop renting to just anyone for the money and take pride in what you do. Rent a quality product to a quality person and see if the home does not receive better care and longer term residents.
Would you would want your own mother to live in one of your homes? Have some common decency to offer a decent product.
Preferred solution: I would like for AMH to clean up their homes and take care of them as if they were going to move in themselves.
User's recommendation: I do NOT recommend AMH to anyone.
This review is from a real person who provided valid contact information and hasn't been caught misusing, spamming or abusing our website. Check our FAQ
Verified ReviewerHorrible Company!
I Currently have over 15 open maintenance requests, some going back 2 years. Currently the AC/Heat hasn't been working for 2 weeks. They totally ignore any request for updates.
They offered me pitiful slap in the face of $50 to get a space heater for an 1800 SQF home.
The head of maintenance is a lowly coward who is to much of a looser to answer the phone or talk to a resident.
They just randomly close requests without any explanation.
AMH is an incredibly horrible company, rent with them at your own peril!
Preferred solution: Price reduction
User's recommendation: Steer clear
No Communcation
I had submitted my paperwork and I had to reach out to them several time to find out where i stood with the application. One person I talked to Kathleen Hisper needed a couple of this.
then we talked to another person( she said that Megan would reach out to me, which did not happen. I called on 2/25 we talked about the income part after a few minutes she stated that yes we qualify for the 4/3 and that she will touch bases on Tue. She did not call on 2/27. It was stated not to transfer any calls to Megan.
Not sure who I spoke with you.(its a different person every time you call) Then on Weds, we made a call again. In so many words you guys.
YOU GUYS DO NOT HOW TO COMMUNICATE AT ALL. I will not recommend this company at all.
About
American Homes For Rent is a company that provides a variety of rental property for U.S. residents to choose from. Company’s corporate office is located in Agoura Hills, California and it has a big amount of residential offices in other U.S. states. American Homes For Rent is aimed at providing of big amount of options for houses choosing: beginning with pricing, ending with detailed information about house amenities. Also, company works with both individuals and businesses and gives houses for rent for different purposes. Company provides both list and map views of property in order for clients to see the exact location of a house.
American Homes 4 Rent is ranked 300 out of 3209 in Real Estate category
USA
Companies Similar to American Homes 4 Rent
Thank You for Your Reply! We are processing your message.
Your comment is successfully posted.
Dealing with similar issue here. They failed to get me a new lease until the 14th of the month - they kept telling me "don't worry about it, we'll get those late charges taken off" - they never did, they accrued until ~$600.00 or so, and then they said "pay it all now or you're out".
No integrity. Don't trust these guys.